| Review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Lens, great buy for the $$!!, Friday, 08 August 2008


Overall rating (weighted)		5.0
Sharpness		5.0
Build Quality		5.0
AF Speed		5.0
Value for Money		5.0

I bought this to go with the new Rebel I bought. EXCELLENT lens, makes the camera look and feel and best of all, take photos like a much higher-end camera. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

1 lens for many events, Friday, 11 July 2008


Overall rating (weighted)		3.8
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		4.0
Value for Money		3.0

i bought this lens to use on vacation or other when i didn't want to carry 2 lenses. this lens does that - i know some of the reviews stated that this lens was not the quality they were looking for but so far, i have seen that.
pro - it's canon, and it covers a lot of range
con - it is a heavier lens

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Great Lense, Thursday, 12 June 2008


Overall rating (weighted)		4.8
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		5.0
AF Speed		5.0
Value for Money		5.0

This is a great mid range zoom lense with the wide
angle of a 28mm. I use this lense with my Canon
40D. It has very good optics and is very easy to
use. A very good value.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Great lens, Saturday, 31 May 2008


Overall rating (weighted)		4.0
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		4.0
Value for Money		4.0

This is great lens that i use all the time. There is only one problem i had and that is dust. After less then a year i got one big peace of dust on the inside of the lens that cost over $100 to have removed.
As long as you take care not to let this happen it is a great lens to have.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful

Great budget lens, Tuesday, 01 April 2008


Overall rating (weighted)		4.3
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		5.0
AF Speed		3.0
Value for Money		5.0

This is a good lens if you are on a budget, I use mine with a digital rebel xti.
Its wide to tele coverage reduces the need to take several lenses, making it a good lens for travelling on foot. As for issues with sharpness, unsharp mask in Adobe Photoshop should take care of that. Sure a 24-105mm L and a 70-200mm F/4 L IS would be great, but once you can work photoshop, this lens should suffice until you can save up a few thousand dollars for these two.
A speedlite EX430/580 would also be a wise investment with this lens.

Why should you care what I think?

My relationship with this item: I own it
Where did you buy this item?: B&H Photo
Price paid: 359
When did you buy this item?: March 15, 2008

Conclusions at a glance

Would you recommend this Item: Yes
Pros: Great wide to tele coverage, nice everyday lens
Cons: A bit on the soft side

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Probably acceptable for most..., Monday, 14 January 2008


Overall rating (weighted)		3.0
Sharpness		3.0
Build Quality		3.0
AF Speed		3.0
Value for Money		3.0

This is a pretty handy lens, given it's 28-200mm range, you can capture almost any scene.

However, if you're a serious hobbyist, and have a desire for tack sharp images, this lens just doesn't cut it. When I had it combined with my Rebel XT, it produced images that were comparable, to slightly better than, old point and shoot. But, even with a tripod, the images produced were too soft for my liking.

That said, I still think this is probably a pretty good starter lens - if you're used to the reach given by super zoom point and shoots, this is probably your best option if you don't have thousands of dollars and don't want to carry a bunch of lenses around with you.

I'm selling mine and upgrading to a Canon EF 70-200mm f/4L.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Great zoom lens, Sunday, 25 March 2007


Overall rating (weighted)		4.5
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		5.0
Value for Money		5.0

I really wanted an IS lens but they were all really expensive. I settled for this on because the price was right and it was a Canon product. I was not disappointed with my selection at all. For an amature photographer this lens will do everything I need it to for now. I may get a wide angle lens. But I think this one will work.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

A good choice for a walk-around lens, Tuesday, 20 March 2007


Overall rating (weighted)		4.0
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		3.0
Value for Money		5.0

This was my first EOS zoom lens, purchased years ago with my original D30. Decent sharpness, decent range, and nice, smooth operation. I personally prefer the 28-135 IS, but if you need the extra reach the 200mm gives you then this is good choice for a walk-around zoom.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

A good film lens, maybe not so good with digital. , Wednesday, 31 January 2007


Overall rating (weighted)		3.8
Sharpness		3.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		4.0
Value for Money		4.0

I got this lens for a wedding I shot. Since I only had one camera at the time, I was afraid of losing shots as I switched back and forth. Since I was in need, I paid full retail price. Couple of comments. You need to have an external flash and be able to do bounce lighting for this lens to be really useful inside. Its a slow lens as the aperature is small. This lens is what I would call an "average" lens. It does everything good but nothing great. The advantages of this lens is the great focal length capability. 28-200mm covers alot of ground. If you travel and you just want to keep memories for yourself and keep your film/digital camera at full auto or f/ 5.6 to 8, you will get great results. use a 580 or a 430 ex flash and that will help compensate for indoors. I think the focal lengths work better for full frame or film cameras over the small sensor digital cameras.

The thing about this lens is the greatest asset of the lens is also the greatest weakness. To be able to provide 28mm-200mm at 350-500 bucks, it requires alot of compromises. Its slow indoors or requires flash which for most people is okay. you will get softness if you blow pictures up past 8x10. Its heavy and long. It doesn't have a small depth of focus for your close ups, it needs to be on a tripod for 200mm unless you can hold it very steady and even then you will want a flash.

If you want a good all around lens under 400.00 this is your lens. If you want to spend a little more you get IS and USM with the 28-135mm. My feeling is, you take great pictures with a lens you have, not a lens you don't have. I think for begineers and for a fun day just shooting regular pictures, this is a great lens. Save the artsy pictures and the emotional pictures for a 50mm 1.4 or a 85mm 1.8 or a up close picture for the 70-200mm. This is a good all around for good pictures, not great ones.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Canon Lens, Sunday, 21 January 2007


Overall rating (weighted)		4.8
Sharpness		5.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		5.0
Value for Money		5.0

I love this lens. It adds a little weight but still able to hold with one hand. It does exactly what you expect it to.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Good Initial Results, Thursday, 18 January 2007


Overall rating (weighted)		4.0
Sharpness		5.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		4.0
Value for Money		3.0

The initial results were excellent, but I must admit I was a little surprised to see how long the lens becomes when at maximum focal length. The weight also intimidated me at first, but when mounted on a Canon Digital Rebel XTi with a battery grip attached, it seems to balance out decently.

I do have to say that, in accordance with other reviews, low light is not a friend of this lens. I haven't done much outdoor photography (due to time contraints, time of the year, etc.), but what I've done has turned out very clear and pleasing. I have a feeling that well-lit outdoor shots is where this lens might excel best.

This is definitely a massive upgrade over the kit lens (in focal length, size, weight, and quality), so be prepared for all four.

I'm not sure if the price justified the purchase, but I think that if good care is taken of this lens, then over time it will surely pay itself off.

Do I recommend? Only if you find the Digital Rebel kit lens too limiting, and want that extra focal length, if you don't mind the extra size, if you have a need for the extra zoom, and are ready for upgrading. Otherwise, practice on the kit lens or a cheaper lens for a while before moving up.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Only One, Wednesday, 10 January 2007


Overall rating (weighted)		4.3
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		5.0
Value for Money		4.0

This lens is the perfect all around zoom for your camera. There is really no need to have to keep switching lenses when this 28-200mm is attached. Quick auto focus and clear pics. The only drawback I have experienced so far is the lack of a lock on the lens. It has a tendency to entend itself from the movement as you walk. But all in all I am extremely satisfied.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Good All-Purpose Lens, Monday, 31 July 2006


Overall rating (weighted)		4.0
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		4.0
Value for Money		4.0

If you're a professional photographer, you can probably ignore this review. But then you probably won't be thinking about buying this lens anyway, as you'll be off to purchase a nice L series.

However, if - like me - you just happen to have a nice Canon Digital Rebel camera (or equivalent) and enjoy taking decent pictures, this lens will probably work out very well for you. I've taken well over 1000 pictures with it in a couple of weeks, and it has performed very much as expected. For the price, it's perfect for a go-everywhere lens.

A few main points. Okay, it's not the best image quality. Even on low/medium ISO it seems a little grainy and its not as sharp as some of the more expensive Canon lenses. It struggles indoors unless you have a good flash unit, but for well-lit outdoor shoots it's works very well.

Of course, it would be nice to have a nice L series with IS, but if you can't afford that then this is a very good value lens. Not for the real professionals, but great if you don't take things too seriously and just want a bit more zoom - and, let's face it, who doesn't want a but more zoom!

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

Abso-bloomin brilliant!, Monday, 22 May 2006


Overall rating (weighted)		4.8
Sharpness		5.0
Build Quality		4.0
AF Speed		5.0
Value for Money		5.0

What a wonderful lens!! I'm purely a hobby shooter, but I do like to take nice shots. I took this to the zoo the other day and was able to take fantastic closeups of the polar bears, even through glass, and pick out the details on the butterfly wings. The lens is not as heavy as I had feared, and unlike some zooms it does not telescope out under its own weight, so it was comfortable enough to keep carrying all day. I'm using it on a Canon D60 and am nothing but pleased with the performance so far.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful

High Quality Lens, Tuesday, 03 January 2006


Overall rating (weighted)		4.3
Sharpness		4.0
Build Quality		5.0
AF Speed		4.0
Value for Money		4.0

I purchased this lens for my Canon EOS 20D digital camera and so far I really like it. It focuses fast and produces very sharp, clear images. As with any longer lens you do have to be careful about camera shake; I've had a few images come out blurry but these are usually interior shots. I really like the 28-200mm focal length range and find the lens to be very versatile for framing wide shots of buildings or landscapes to zoomed in shots for portraits or close detail shots. The lens feels solid and appears to be well constructed, which is typical for Canon products. For the price range, this is an excellent lens. You can only do better by spending considerable more money on an IS lens.

Was this review helpful to you? yes

Report this review

Most Popular...